Hey,

Who are we brewing for? Who are we making coffee for?

That can be as simple as me. Or you. Or it can be pretty layered.

A while back I wrote you a letter about figuring out what I actually like. Medium to dark, washed process, that spot where sweetness and acidity talk to each other. Finding that took me years, and when I wrote it, I honestly thought it was the end of the story. I knew my palate now. Case closed.

It wasn't the end of the story. Because knowing what I like didn't stop me from making other people's coffee. It just made the ghosts harder to spot.

So this letter is about the who.

Ghost number one: the reviewer

I'm not going to lie, sometimes some of those gurus online get me. Sometimes I follow their recipes. Sometimes I roast the way they want me to roast. Well, in the past I did.

And watch what I was doing at the end. I wasn't tasting my cup and asking whether I liked it. I was tasting my cup and asking whether it matched. Their palate was the answer key. Mine was the student showing work.

Here's the thing I understand now that I didn't then. We get advice, we read articles, maybe books, probably not that much. But a lot of people giving that advice are not giving us context. They don't know your water, your grinder, your kitchen, your Tuesday. So even when we don't get it right following their way, we have to realize we're the ones who are actually making the coffee.

Ghost number two: the bag

Tasting notes. I can tell you the notes on the bag. I can tell you that you're going to be tasting Starburst, Jasmine, and Oolong Tea. I can tell you all of that. But truthfully, it doesn't matter. It depends on what you care about.

I've stood at my counter hunting for a note the way you look for your keys. It says jasmine. Where's the jasmine. Am I getting jasmine, or am I talking myself into jasmine? And if I didn't find it, one of us failed, and I usually decided it was me.

The cup stops being a drink in that scene. It becomes a test somebody else wrote.

Ghost number three: the people at your table

This one's real, not imagined. Family, co-workers, people with requests. If you like lightly roasted, acidic coffees, do you think they'll like it? Will it go right with their milk and sugar? Would they look at you crazy for brewing this type of coffee? Would you look at them crazy for drinking coffee that way?

That's their journey. They're just interjecting it on you.

And then I became a roaster, and the ghost moved upstream

Here's the part where you'd expect the story to end. I roast my own coffee now. No bag, nobody's recipe between me and the bean. Surely that's the exit.

It moved the problem one step back. When I buy green coffee, it comes with notes too. The importer tasted it, scored it, wrote up what they found. Sometimes there are even roasting notes, this is what's going to happen with this coffee. And for a while, I caught myself selecting coffees while already tasting somebody else's description. Roasting toward their promise, and feeling that same old failure when my version didn't produce their words.

What changed

I've been doing this a long time now, and the notes didn't go away. My relationship to them flipped.

When I'm buying greens, the notes are a starting place. I read between the lines. Okay, I can see that flavor. That's where I want to play around. And from there I either buy it or I don't. Then I try to see if I can craft that coffee to be something more than what it is, if that makes any sense.

And once the coffee is here and I'm dialing it in, I don't even look at the importer's notes anymore. I figure the coffee out on my own terms first. Then, sometimes, if I have a decent amount left and I've got it where I want it, I'll go back and read what they wrote. Oh, okay. I can see where they're coming from with this note and that note. Just to see how close we are to the same thing.

Catch what happened there. The notes used to grade me before I ever tasted the coffee. Now they wait until I'm done, and we compare. Same piece of paper. Completely different job. It went from being the answer key to being another taster at the table, one I check in with after I've made up my own mind.

Whose journey is it really?

At the end of the day, each and every one of us is just at home, making coffee for ourselves. I'm the one drinking my cup. You're the one drinking yours.

And I want to say this part directly, because it's really the whole letter: you're doing this for yourself, more than anything. So figure out your own thing. Your own likes, your own dislikes, and your own reasons why. Not the category you fit in. Two people can both be "light roast people" and not be the same person at all. One of them is chasing the brightness, the other one's chasing the florals, and a third one just likes the idea of being a light roast person. The label agrees. The reasons don't. And the reasons are the part that's actually yours.

So that's the way I see it, and I think that's the way we should operate: all of this is just a suggestion. The reviewer's recipe. The bag. The importer's writeup. Even this letter. Suggestions. You're the one who's actually making the coffee.

Once we figure that out, we'll be in a better place. Your target market is you. It's you.

Your turn

So ask yourself the question. Who are you brewing your coffee for?

Hopefully it's for yourself. Hopefully it's for the reasons you deeply care about. And if you don't know, this is your opportunity to find out.

Hit reply and answer it honestly. I did, and my answer took a few years to get right.

Oaks, the Coffee Guy

"Just keep reading. I've got you."

A winding road at dawn, standing in for the long road of learning coffee.

Here's to the journey. Yours and mine.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate